About the Episode
Got a story to tell? An innovative idea to share? Fill out our guest nomination form and let's chat!
About the Episode:
Jenny Li Fowler sits down with Rochelle Reed, Social Media Manager at James Madison University (JMU), to unpack how Instagram Stories evolved from an overlooked feature into a strategic powerhouse for campus engagement. Rochelle shares how JMU has built a data-driven Instagram Stories strategy that prioritizes interaction, authenticity, and smart storytelling. This episode is a goldmine for anyone serious about leveling up their social content game.
Key Takeaways
- Instagram Stories deserve strategy: JMU tracks retention, interactions, and impressions for every Story—over four years of data!
- Interaction is everything: Sliders, polls, and sticker taps skyrocket engagement. Students want to participate—just give them the chance.
- User-generated content (UGC) wins: Smart curation of campus content from students leads to higher views, more taps, and better retention.
- Don't be precious about Stories: Stories are the perfect space to experiment, fail fast, and learn—even if the content only lives for 24 hours.
- Let go to grow: Rochelle’s honest confession? Caring less about perfection made her a stronger social media manager.
Episode Summary
Your FAQ Guide to Smarter Instagram Stories from JMU’s Rochelle Reed
Why should higher ed take Instagram Stories seriously?
Rochelle Reed believes that Stories are one of the most underutilized tools in the higher ed marketing toolkit. Often dismissed due to their 24-hour lifespan, Stories at JMU are treated like prime real estate. They provide real-time campus insights, require less polish than feed posts, and serve as dynamic touchpoints for high-impact storytelling. JMU doesn’t just “wing it”—they strategically track every Story’s performance, with retention rate, interactions, and link clicks as key metrics. In fact, Stories have become so embedded in their strategy that they now have four years of Instagram Story data guiding their content decisions.
How is JMU using analytics to shape its Instagram Stories?
At JMU, Instagram Stories aren’t an afterthought—they’re a deliberate strategy backed by data. Rochelle’s team tracks each Story’s first frame impressions, last frame impressions, interaction types, and number of frames, calculating retention rates and learning what formats resonate. They even benchmark against themselves month over month and year over year, aiming for an average 87–90% retention rate across Stories. Using this data, they’ve refined everything from optimal post days (Fridays = lower views) to Story length (stick to 10–12 frames to avoid fatigue). The result? Highly engaging, intentionally curated Stories that audiences actually watch.
What types of content perform best on Stories?
Two words: interactivity and community. Sliders, polls, sticker taps, and Q&A boxes drive major engagement because they invite viewers to be part of the experience. JMU’s audience loves to give feedback—whether it’s how excited they are for game day or tapping over to see who’s taking over the account. UGC also plays a huge role. During high-profile events like College GameDay, JMU shared photos and videos from students tagging the university, leading to massive increases in impressions, engagement, and retention. They strategically balance branded content with curated community posts for maximum effect.
How does JMU manage Story takeovers without handing over the password?
One of the most scalable and secure practices JMU follows is coordinated Story takeovers—without giving anyone direct account access. Campus partners and students request a takeover slot via a form, attend a 30-minute consultation, and then submit their Story assets in advance. JMU’s social team reviews and posts the content, adding interactions like stickers and links as needed. This allows for brand consistency, ADA compliance (captioning!), and oversight—while still elevating authentic voices. Plus, JMU shares performance data with every takeover participant, deepening campus-wide collaboration.
What's Rochelle's ultimate Instagram Stories confession?
Her bold (and refreshingly honest) confession?
“Caring less about my job actually made me better at it.”
Rochelle doesn’t mean apathy—she means letting go of perfectionism and treating Stories as an agile, experimental space. This mindset shift helped her stop over-engineering content, become more open to collaboration, and embrace flexibility. In higher ed, where decisions are often weighed down by process and precedent, this philosophy is powerful. Stories don’t need to be flawless—they need to be real, responsive, and resonant.
Connect With Our Host:
https://twitter.com/TheJennyLi
About The Enrollify Podcast Network:
Confessions of a Higher Ed Social Media Manager is a part of the Enrollify Podcast Network. If you like this podcast, chances are you’ll like other Enrollify shows, too!
Some of our favorites include Higher Ed Pulse and Confessions of a Higher Ed CMO.
Enrollify is produced by Element451 — the next-generation AI student engagement platform helping institutions create meaningful and personalized interactions with students. Learn more at element451.com.
.svg)
.svg)
